Magic Bullet Vs NutriBullet

The Magic Bullet Vs NutriBullet debate poses a question whether you should skimp or splurge on your bullet-style blender. We’ll try to give you the answers you need in this roundup.

There’s no surprise that there’s a Magic Bullet vs NutriBullet debate going on among consumers. Both items promise the same solid performance and reliable quality since they’re from the same manufacturer. Magic Bullet is just the more affordable line of NutriBullet, so you are promised the same quality by both brands. It all boils down to a few key details that really set them apart. Despite the distinct differences, however, it’s still understandable why lots of people have a hard time choosing between the two.

Nutribullet-VS-Magic-Bullet blender

When pitting two items, however, there’s always a chance that one will come out on top of the other. One product can just be better, overall, than the other or one would be a better match for the needs and situations of a specific consumer. Either way, it’s not impossible to choose one over the other, especially between these two bullet-style blenders. If you want to know which one would be a better pick for you, let’s closely examine the original Magic Bullet vs the NutriBullet Pro.

Touching Base: A Close Look at Blender Bases

When it comes to nutrient extractors and blenders, the motor is always among the most important considerations so it’s just fitting to start with this part. Both bullet blenders have compact bases but are rather miles apart when it comes to power.

Why? The Magic Bullet only has a 250-watt motor while the other is 900 watts. That’s nearly four times the power, guaranteeing that it can be more efficient and capable of crushing, blending, and chopping ingredients.

In terms of appearance, however, they’re not too different design-wise but you have different color options for the NutriBullet Pro, so that’s a plus.  The higher-powered pick is also bigger and may feel a bit more solid due to the kinds of materials used.

The winner: The NutriBullet offers more power so it promises more efficiency and effectiveness in giving you high-quality results. This tends to be a must for nutrient extractors and food prep appliances. However, if you don’t believe that you’ll be needing too much power for the purpose you have in mind for your bullet blender, then the Magic Bullet can still be a solid choice.

Container Comparison

The containers of these types of blenders set them apart from other kinds of blenders but they can still come in different shapes and sizes. The NutriBullet comes with large containers, 2 tall 32 oz cups. It seems fitting for the amount of power the motor has as it can definitely handle more ingredients in one go.

The Magic Bullet, on the other hand, comes with smaller containers. One has an 18 oz capacity, one can hold up to 12 oz, and there’s another smaller ‘party mug’. The details are not easy to find regarding the cup sizes, though, as they’re not noted in most listings.

Due to the bullet style, however, the covers that come with these two products are different from what you’ll find in regular blenders. There are 2 kinds of covers that come with these blenders. One has the blade and the other is a resealable lid. Both products also come with comfort lip rings which will allow you to drink comfortably from the containers.

The Magic Bullet comes with 1 cross blade lid and 2 stay-fresh lids while the NutriBullet comes with a Nutrient Extractor blade and 2 to-go lids.

The winner: It’s probably a tie when it comes to this area as the containers that come with the two products seem to be proportional to their motor power. As a result, reliable results can be expected from both.

Slice and Dice: Some Blade Talk

As mentioned above, the Magic Bullet comes with one cross blade while the NutriBullet comes with a Nutrient Extractor blade. With these, it can be said  that the latter offers more functionality.

The cross blade only has two blades while the Nutrient Extractor blade comes with four blades. This makes a lot of difference because it offers more efficiency. Combined with its high-powered motor, the pricier pick offers more promising results.

The winner: The NutriBullet takes the cake here as it simply has more blades to work with. This and the motor’s power can do a lot of great things without breaking a sweat.

The Sound of Bullets: How Loud Can These Blenders Be

One of the advantages of bullet-style blenders is that their smaller physical size and lower motor power make them slightly quieter than full-sized high-power blenders. They’re still quite loud while in operation but it’s significantly more quiet than other blenders.

Between the two, the Magic Bullet is more quiet. This probably has a lot to do with its small motor but it won’t cause as much of a ruckus than other blenders. With the 900-watt power of the other bullet blender, it really just can’t compare.

The winner: Magic Bullet wins this round because it is significantly more quiet when in operation.

Quick and Easy Blending

Another key characteristic of bullet-style blenders is the fact that they don’t even have control panels to fuss with. All you have to do is to secure the blade lid onto the container, place it on the power base, and push down to start blending. You also have the option to lock the container in place for hands-free blending. If you wish to pulse, however, it’s best to keep your grip on the container so you can push down intermittently on it.

The winner: Both products are operated the same way, so it’s a tie for ease of use. It’s also the same with cleaning, since both have removable blades and dishwasher-safe parts.

Size Matters: Comparing Measurements

This is another area where these two products can go head to head. Their sizes are significantly different, so if you have a preference, you’ll be able to decide on this area.

Obviously, the NutriBullet Pro is bigger with its 32 oz containers. The base is heavier and has a wider footprint, so it will take up a significant amount of space on your countertop. You’ll get more servings with this pick, though. So if you love having large portions of smoothies or if you need to whip up large batches of food regularly, this would be a good choice.

If you just need a personal-size bullet blender, however, the Magic Bullet will already suffice. Its 18 oz cup will already give you a fulfilling fix of whatever you wish to make.

The winner: The sizes of the two products are significantly different for them to appeal to different segments of the market. It really depends on the buyer which one they find more suitable to their needs in terms of the size.

Other Stuff: Extras and Warranty

Unlike other pricey blenders, our two featured items come with extras even in their most basic set. Both come with extra containers, lids, and lip rings. NutriBullet Pro also comes with additional lip rings with handles.

It should also be noted that both products have available additional accessories. You can get other styles of blades for the Magic Bullet as well as shaker and steamer lids, though, so you can further do more with this item.

As for product guarantee, the NutriBullet Pro offers a more attractive coverage. The Magic Bullet only comes with a one-year limited warranty while the other has an additional limited four year warranty on top of its one-year limited warranty. This makes it a more promising pick as it might really last longer.

The winner: With the availability of a wider range of accessories for Magic Bullet, it seems like it can offer you to do more. So if you’re the type who likes to use different accessories with your kitchen appliances, this might tickle your fancy. However, for the warranty, NutriBullet Pro’s is hard to beat.

Overall Performance: How Well These Bullet Blenders Work

Since our two featured products have significant differences in terms of features, it can be expected that they will perform somewhat differently, too. But how different will they be from each other? Let’s take a look.

When Making Smoothies

As bullet-style blenders are designed for making single-serve smoothies, you can expect both products to provide good results. However, one can handle more ingredients better than the other. You can also check some other best rated blenders for smoothies if you want.

The Magic Bullet, due to its lower motor power, isn’t as stellar as the NutriBullet Pro in handling harder ingredients. This means that frozen fruits and ice as well as hard vegetables can strain its motor. If you’ll stick with softer ingredients, however, you can expect excellent results from this product.

When Making Nut Butters

Nut butters require a lot of power to make, so if you have a NutriBullet Pro, this shouldn’t be a problem. This product is perfectly capable of handling hard ingredients, so you can expect to make smooth and creamy nut butters with it.

On the flip side, many users have already proven that the Magic Bullet can make nut butters. It requires some patience and great care, however. Due to the hardness of the nuts, it’s recommended not to run the bullet blender on high. It’s ideal to keep pulsing it instead to carefully grind and break the nuts. This will take a while, so patience is needed. It can give you good results with the right tricks, though.

When whipping up hot soups

It is not recommended to make hot soups in both the NutriBullet Pro and the Magic Bullet. This might be due to the bullet style as the steam can expand inside the container with nowhere to go. You can certainly puree room temperature or cold ingredients in these products but it’s not recommended to make hot soups in them.

Some might argue that the manuals and fine print for the Magic Bullet may imply that it can handle hot ingredients but it’s certainly not the case. There’s even a steam lid for this item, so it’s hard to deny that they are suggesting that you can do such a thing but it’s best to just not do it. This product can overheat, especially with a hot liquid in it.

As for the NutriBullet, the manufacturer specifically states not to put hot ingredients in it.

When making frozen drinks and desserts

As mentioned before, the Magic Bullet can have a hard time handling hard ingredients like ice so it’s not recommended for making frozen drinks and desserts. If you wish to use lots of ice in your blended beverages, then the NutriBullet Pro will be a more suitable choice with its higher powered motor.

When chopping and processing cooking ingredients

Both the Magic Bullet and NutriBullet Pro are capable of chopping and processing ingredients for cooking. Again, however, you might need to stick with the softer ingredients with the former due to its motor power. With such precautions in mind, though, you’ll be able to get the results you want from both products.

When pureeing

You can make purees with beautiful textures with both products. Just make sure that the ingredients are not hot anymore before running them in the bullet blenders to ensure safety.

The Magic Bullet

PROS
CONS
  • Not recommended for hard ingredients
  • Not capable of whipping up

The NutriBullet

PROS
CONS
  • Extensive warranty coverage
  • High-powered motor
  • Can easily handle all kinds of ingredients and various blending tasks
  • Very easy to use and clean
  • 5-year warranty
  • Large capacity
  • Quite noisy
  • Has a lot of plastic parts

Conclusion: Which is Better, the Magic Bullet or NutriBullet Pro?

With everything said above, it’s easy to see that the NutriBullet Pro tends to outperform the Magic Bullet in most areas. It’s stronger with its higher powered motor so it’s definitely a multi-tasker. This will give you more bang for your buck as you can use it for various purposes.

However, the Magic Bullet isn’t too bad if you don’t really need a lot from a bullet blender. If you just need something cheap and handy that you can use to make some fruit smoothies and protein shakes, it’s perfect for the job.

It’s definitely up to you which one will suit your needs. As these two products are distinctly different, they might appeal to different consumers.